Project

Differences in planning culture

Spatial planning is largely a cultural activity because it impinges directly on political, social and economic issues. Planning concepts, development processes and planning decisions are always influenced by the cultural backgrounds of social groups and individuals, and cultural differences are one of the obstacles to successful planning.

culture

Cooperation between actors is complicated by their different perceptions of the meaning of space and understanding of planning systems and processes. This can be a particular problem in international projects because planning traditions and decision-making processes may vary considerably between the countries involved.

The CULTPLAN project addresses the management of different planning cultures and contexts in INTERREG projects. It is based on the assumption that many problems arise from differences in the cultural backgrounds of the cooperating partners. Project managers who are able to cope with this issue can exploit such cultural differences to good effect: positive energy can be generated if project work is allied to traditional ways of working and planning.

CULTPLAN aims to articulate and exchange best practices on managing differences between planning cultures within programmes and projects. A further objective is to formulate conclusions and recommendations for managing cultural differences in future initiatives and international planning processes. Learning from and adapting working practices to the different planning cultures will contribute to the success of the INTERREG III programmes and projects. An analytical framework has been constructed which recognises different levels within projects and programmes, such as a project team, plans and planning processes, and implementation level. Taking the example of communicative aspects within a transnational team, the relevant issues at a higher level include traditions in using design strategies, concepts and visualisation techniques in plan-making processes.

Characteristic implementation strategies associated with the cultural identity of a nation or region will also be taken into account. The concept of culture is broken down into horizontal and vertical components. The horizontal component consists of cultural segments that are manifest at the same level: how individuals live together (social institutions), who controls whom (political institutions), how knowledge, ideas and values are disseminated between individuals and groups (language and communication in the widest sense), etc. The vertical component deals with the manifest and more hidden aspects of culture: the immediately observable symbols, morals, patterns and norms, etc. These aspects will be further elaborated in cooperation with Aalborg University.

The analysis of INTERREG III projects (Strand A, B and C) will focus on the influence the cultural context exerts on planning processes. All the partners will work on at least 20 case studies, each of which will consist of a desk study of documents concerning the project and several interviews on location. A questionnaire will be sent to INTERREG participants across Europe to collect statistical and empirical material about the cultural determinants in INTERREG programmes and projects. The scientific elaboration of the project is supervised by the Belvedere professors in Delft, Amsterdam and Wageningen.

More information